Tiburon, California · Marin Peninsula

Tiburon's cameras were searched 16,029 times. Almost none of it was legal.

41 outside agencies ran 16,029 potentially illegal searches of our town's license-plate cameras in six months, including audits for federal immigration agencies. The town expanded access while it was investigating itself. [The Ark, 2026]

Email the Town Council Show up at the next meeting
Watch · 60 seconds

The asset you forgot to protect.

What the audit found
16,029
potentially illegal searches of Tiburon's logs, Jul to Dec
41
outside agencies that ran them, including audits for ICE, CBP, HSI
+45%
access Tiburon added during its own internal investigation

Source: The Ark investigation & follow-up audit, 2026. Tiburon Police Chief Michelle Jean acknowledged 23 agencies ran potentially illegal federal searches.

The part the town left out

You were told 30 days. That's the police. Flock keeps it.

The "30-day retention" on the transparency portal is the police department's access window. Flock Safety is not the government. It is a private, venture-funded company in Atlanta, and a different set of rules applies to it.

Perpetual license

The police lose access. Flock doesn't.

Flock's own terms grant the company an "irrevocable, perpetual" license to use your data to "support and improve" its products. The 30-day window doesn't bind that.

[Flock Terms & Conditions; ACLU analysis]
The dropped promise

It quietly removed its no-sale clause.

Flock's contract used to say it "shall not sell Customer Data." The ACLU documents that the sentence was removed from the terms. The guardrail is gone.

[ACLU, "Flock's Terms and Conditions"]
You can't FOIA a company

No public records over a private vendor.

You can file a Public Records Act request to the Tiburon police. You cannot file one against a venture-funded company. The accountability stops at the town line.

[California Public Records Act applies to agencies, not private firms]
Funded to grow

It is built to monetize.

Flock has raised over $950M and is valued around $8 billion. A company that size has investors to repay, and your movements are the product.

[TechCrunch, 2025; reported valuation 2026]

One local search queries a national network. Outside agencies have tapped Flock's nationwide system for thousands of immigration lookups through local police, with no Flock contract of their own. The camera on your street is a doorway into all of it. [404 Media; EFF]

In our own paper

The Ark did the reporting. Read it.

Two investigations by Tiburon's own newspaper documented all of this from public records.

"41 California law-enforcement agencies conducted 16,029 potentially illegal searches of Tiburon's automated license-plate logs from July through December."
The Ark, follow-up audit
"These systems are collecting data on everybody, not just people suspected of crimes, but everyone who drives."
Matt Cagle, ACLU of Northern California
"Tiburon continued to expand the number of agencies with access to its database by 45% during its internal investigation."
The Ark
"These drop-downs effectively give law enforcement options for how to avoid being transparent and honest about why they're using the system."
Nick Hidalgo, ACLU of Northern California
It is not out of your hands

Five people decide this. They work for you.

Tiburon's cameras are not a law of nature. They are a vendor contract and a police policy, approved by the Town Council, the Town Manager, and the Police Chief. Surveillance contracts in towns this size often pass quietly on the consent calendar. The fix is to make it loud and on the record.

Mayor
Jon Welner
Vice Mayor
Isaac Nikfar
Councilmember
Alice Fredericks
Councilmember
Jack Ryan
Councilmember
Holli Thier
Town Manager
Greg Chanis

Write to them now, get counted →

Town Council: town@townoftiburon.org · 415-435-7373. Police Chief: Michelle Jean. Council meets the 1st & 3rd Wednesday, 6:30pm, 1505 Tiburon Blvd. townoftiburon.org/Town-Council

You don't need thousands

A dozen neighbors who show up is the whole game.

These are five-person councils. They hear from almost no one. A handful of residents at one meeting has turned cameras off across the country.

Sedona AZ
12 residents spoke against the cameras at one special meeting (2 spoke for). The council voted 5-1 that night to shut them off, then terminated the contract and removed all 11.
Lever: one packed meeting
Belvedere CA · next door
One day after The Ark's first investigation, the police chief cut off every outside agency except six in Marin, and released the search data. No vote required.
Lever: the news report next door
Evanston IL
A state audit found Flock let federal agents access plate data in violation of state law. The city terminated the contract and deactivated all 19 cameras.
Lever: an official audit
Cambridge MA
A council that approved cameras 6-3 reversed to a unanimous vote to suspend them, then ended the contract, after residents and the ACLU pressed the data-sharing conflict.
Lever: organized residents
South Pasadena CA
After reports that local data reached federal immigration agencies, the council voted 4-1 to end one Flock contract and let the other lapse.
Lever: a 4-1 council vote
Denver CO
After months of public pressure, the council declined to renew Flock on a 7-6 vote. One vote decided it.
Lever: a single vote

Sources: Red Rock News (Sedona); The Ark (Belvedere); Evanston RoundTable; Harvard Crimson (Cambridge); LAist (South Pasadena); 9News (Denver).

Do these. Today.

Three moves that actually work.

Email the Town Council

One firm, non-partisan email. Ask them to pull Flock off the consent calendar, end outside and federal access like Belvedere did, and say in writing what Flock keeps. Copy the draft below, add your name, send it.

to: town@townoftiburon.org
Open it in your email
Ready-to-send email
Dear Mayor Welner and members of the Town Council,

I am a Tiburon resident. The Ark has documented that 41 outside agencies ran 16,029 potentially illegal searches of our town's license-plate cameras in six months, including audits for federal immigration agencies. I am asking the Council to:

1. Put Tiburon's Flock/ALPR program on a public agenda, not the consent calendar.
2. End all outside-agency and federal access, as Belvedere did.
3. Tell residents in writing what Flock the company retains after the police department's 30-day window, and what its contract allows.
4. Consider ending the contract, as Sedona, Evanston and South Pasadena have.

The cameras scan everyone, and the data leaves town. Please restore the boundary line.

[Your name and street]

Show up at the next council meeting

Two minutes of public comment, in person, is worth a hundred emails. Sedona turned its cameras off after twelve people spoke at one meeting. Bring a neighbor.

1st & 3rd Wednesday · 6:30pm · 1505 Tiburon Blvd · public comment via the Town Clerk, 415-435-7377

File a public records request

Make the town show the contract, the audit logs, and who has access. It is your right, it is free, and it forces the paper trail into daylight. Copy the request below and email it to the Town Clerk.

Public Records Act request
To the Town Clerk, Town of Tiburon:

Under the California Public Records Act (Gov. Code section 7920.000 et seq.), I request copies of the following records:

1. The current Flock Safety contract or order form, and any amendments.
2. The ALPR network audit logs for the past 12 months, including the searching agency, the username, and the stated reason for each search.
3. All data-sharing agreements and the current list of agencies with access to Tiburon's ALPR data.
4. Tiburon Police Department Policy 414 (ALPR) and any revisions.

Please provide these records electronically. If any portion is withheld, please cite the specific exemption.

[Your name and contact email]
This is the Tiburon edition

Not Tiburon?

Same machine, different town. We will build your town its own page, with your council, your numbers, and your draft emails.

Start your town's page